Used BMW X1 (2009 - 2015) Review

Review by David Ross on
Last Updated: 02 Sep 2014
4
This is the German company’s fourth X model - the BMW X1 - is also the smallest, yet retains much of the practicality and spaciousness of its larger counterparts. It's slightly shorter than a 3-Series which makes it easy to manoeuvre and park, especially in town, and yet still has impressive space for passengers in the back as well as a large and useful boot.

BMW X1 (09-15)
  • Economical diesel engines with low CO2 emissions
  • Available with two or four-wheel drive
  • Large boot area
  • Some rather cheap feeling interior plastics
  • Firm ride

New price range:

£24,230 - £34,960

Used price range:

£3,437 - £15,856

View all used prices

Summary

Parkers Rating:

4 out of 5

This is the German company’s fourth X model - the BMW X1 - is also the smallest, yet retains much of the practicality and spaciousness of its larger counterparts. It's slightly shorter than a 3-Series which makes it easy to manoeuvre and park, especially in town, and yet still has impressive space for passengers in the back as well as a large and useful boot.

It's available with either two-wheel drive (badged sDrive) or four-wheel drive (xDrive) while all the engines are impressively efficient and economical diesels, giving the X1 low running costs.

There are criticisms, including some unusually below-par plastics in the cabin and a rather notchy gearshift on manual models, but decent levels of standard equipment, the usual BMW build quality and superb refinement make the X1 a sound choice.

Economical engines

Where the BMW X1’s key rival, the Audi Q3, has an engine range where only one motor gets above the 50mpg mark, the X1 has only a single engine that dips below this figure – the xDrive25d with its 47.9mpg. The rest of the X1 range all comfortable exceed this economy figure and, in the case of the sDrive 20d EfficientDynamics, offers 62.8mpg and carbon dioxide emissions of just 119g/km.

This makes the X1 a sound choice for company car drivers and private owners alike thanks to the BMW’s low running costs. The only real downside is the BMW is not available with an automatic gearbox, which the Q3 is, though this does help keep the X1’s fuel economy high.

Disappointing interior

While most BMWs are exemplars of quality and high standards of build, the X1 is a little disappointing in this department. In particular, around the centre console between the front seats feels cheap and cheerless when compared to the Audi Q3 or Honda CR-V. Some other plastics feel raw and unfinished if you fish your hands underneath the seats or deeper beyond the superficial dash.

However, the fit of the materials appears first rate, so we have no reason to believe the X1 won’t hold together well over time. Also, the rest of the cabin has the same air of classy build we’d expect of a BMW. To find out more read the full BMW X1 4x4 review.

Parkers Ratings

Overall

4 out of 5

Performance

4 out of 5

Handling

4 out of 5

Comfort

3.5 out of 5

Practicality

4.5 out of 5

Behind the wheel

4 out of 5

Safety

4.5 out of 5

Reliability

4.5 out of 5

Running costs

4 out of 5

Green credentials

4.5 out of 5

Buying used

3.5 out of 5

Selling

4 out of 5

Equipment

4 out of 5

What owners say...

 Wide-opening doors; good adjustable seats and controls; rear seats tilt to multiple positions for bulky loads. General joyful grip and handling. Reassuringly poised on the road. Measured average of...  

4 out of 5

Mike Hindson-Evans ,   01 Apr 2016    ... read more

 Good driving position, sure footed road presence and good build quality.  

5 out of 5

Richard Evans ,   01 Apr 2015    ... read more

 Proving to be very economical. Being four wheel drive, it is wonderful to drive around the muddy country lanes! I had a 1 series M sport before this and it was lovely to drive on dry smooth roads, but...  

5 out of 5

Kate Waldron ,   10 Jan 2015    ... read more

See all Owners' Reviews

Next steps

Best deals on BMW X1 Estates